Civic Intelligence

Ventura Audubon Society

EIN 95-3538623 • 501(c)3 • Ventura, CA

Profile

The mission of the Ventura Audubon Society is to promote at the local level, by education and action, the protection and restoration of bird populations and wildlife habitat for the benefit of humanity and the earth's biodiversity.

PO Box 24198Ventura, CA 93002

www.venturaaudubon.org

Siviq Scores

Precomputed percentiles relative to similar nonprofits. These scores are descriptive rather than judgmental.

Liabilities / Assets

59th percentile

0.00x

Tied with the lowest-debt nonprofits in its peer group.

501(c)3 • <$500k nonprofits • Source year 2025

Liabilities / Revenue

61st percentile

0.00x

Tied with the lowest-debt nonprofits in its peer group.

501(c)3 • <$500k nonprofits • Source year 2025

Net Margin

94th percentile

69%

Higher net margin than 94% of similar nonprofits.

501(c)3 • <$500k nonprofits • Source year 2025

Top Officer Pay

88th percentile

$8,670

Higher top officer pay than 88% of similar nonprofits.

Top officer pay equals 5.4% of source-year revenue.

501(c)3 • <$500k nonprofits • Source year 2023

Asset Growth

97th percentile

256%

Faster asset growth than 97% of similar nonprofits.

501(c)3 • <$500k nonprofits • Annualized from 2024 to 2025

Revenue Growth

84th percentile

49%

Faster revenue growth than 84% of similar nonprofits.

501(c)3 • <$500k nonprofits • Annualized from 2024 to 2025

Assets

Up

$300,562

Up $216,044 (+256%) from 2024

Liabilities

Flat

$0

Flat from 2024

Net Assets

Up

$300,562

Up $216,044 (+256%) from 2024

Revenue

Up

$314,685

Up $103,154 (+49%) from 2024

Expenses

Down

$98,641

Down $95,581 (-49%) from 2024

Net Income

Up

$216,044

Up $198,735 (+1148%) from 2024

Trend Graphs

Balance Sheet Trend

Grouped bars show assets, liabilities, and net assets across loaded filings.

$400K$300K$200K$100K$0Assets 2017: $42,506Liabilities 2017: $02017Assets 2018: $40,228Net Assets 2018: $40,2282018Assets 2019: $46,612Net Assets 2019: $46,6122019Assets 2020: $32,982Liabilities 2020: $02020Assets 2021: $38,123Net Assets 2021: $38,1232021Assets 2022: $39,054Liabilities 2022: $02022Assets 2023: $67,209Net Assets 2023: $67,2092023Assets 2024: $84,518Liabilities 2024: $0Net Assets 2024: $84,5182024Assets 2025: $300,562Liabilities 2025: $0Net Assets 2025: $300,5622025

Highlighted filing

2025

Assets$300,562
Liabilities$0
Net Assets$300,562

Operations Trend

Revenue, expenses, and net income by year, with the latest filing highlighted.

$400K$300K$200K$100K$0-$100KRevenue 2017: $54,243Expenses 2017: $61,069Net Income 2017: -$6,8262017Revenue 2018: $59,985Expenses 2018: $62,263Net Income 2018: -$2,2782018Revenue 2019: $51,780Expenses 2019: $45,396Net Income 2019: $6,3842019Revenue 2020: $40,777Expenses 2020: $54,407Net Income 2020: -$13,6302020Revenue 2021: $107,659Expenses 2021: $102,518Net Income 2021: $5,1412021Revenue 2022: $156,302Expenses 2022: $155,371Net Income 2022: $9312022Revenue 2023: $159,776Expenses 2023: $131,621Net Income 2023: $28,1552023Revenue 2024: $211,531Expenses 2024: $194,222Net Income 2024: $17,3092024Revenue 2025: $314,685Expenses 2025: $98,641Net Income 2025: $216,0442025

Highlighted filing

2025

Revenue$314,685
Expenses$98,641
Net Income$216,044

Filings

Latest Detailed Filing

The latest 2025 filing currently has linked XML that has not been fully parsed yet. Showing the latest detailed filing from 2023 below.

Jump To
Filing Snapshot
Filing Period
Jul 1, 2022 to Jun 30, 2023
Signed
Nov 7, 2023
Return Version
2022v5.0
Gross Receipts
$159,776
Mission and Program Overview

Mission

The mission of the Ventura Audubon Society is to promote at the local level, by education and action, the protection and restoration of bird populations and wildlife habitat for the benefit of humanity and the earth's biodiversity.

Program Services

DescriptionGrantsExpenses
Shorebird Recovery Program$56,070$74,993
NFWF$43,700$43,700
Education-$3,413
Compensation and Service Providers

Employees

NameTitleFull / Part TimeBaseOtherTotal
CYNTHIA HARTLEYExecutive Director-$8,670-$8,670
ALECIA SMITHDirectorPT$7,173-$7,173
DEBRA BARRINGERDirector-$5,960-$5,960
RACHEL AMECHEVice President-$0--
LINDSAY TALLYDirector-$0--
KAITLYN ODEADirector-$0--
SANDY HEDRICKDirectorPT$0--
FRANK DeMARTINODirector-$0--
SABRINA KENNEDYSecretary-$0--
VINCE KINSCHPresident-$0--
SHERRY DORRISTreasurer-$0--
Filing and Contact Details

Filer

Filer Name
Ventura Audubon Society
EIN
95-3538623
Phone
8056284044
Address
PO BOX 24198, VENTURA, CA 93002

Signing Officer

Name
Vince Kinsch
Title
President
Signed
2023-11-07
Discuss with paid preparer
Yes

Preparer

Firm
Hayman Consulting
Address
4616 TEMPLETON ST, VENTURA, CA 93003
Preparer
Mark Hayman
Phone
8054077599
Supplemental Narrative

Additional Explanations

Other Expenses.1001

Advertising and Promotion $71

Other Expenses.1002

Office Expenses $520

Other Expenses.1003

Information Technology $1132

Other Expenses.1012

Insurance $2500

Other Expenses.1

PROGRAM EXPENSES $100303

Other Expenses.2

SOFTWARE $1825

Other Expenses.3

BIRDATHON $1232

Other Expenses.4

STORAGE $684

Other Expenses.5

SPECIAL PROJECTS $440

Other Expenses.6

BANK FEES $264

Other Expenses.8

Taxes $75

Other Expenses.9

FEES $10

Raw XML Appendix203 raw XML fields

This appendix keeps the raw XML leaves available for debugging and edge-case review. The human report above is the primary experience.

Path#Value
IRS990EZ/ActivitiesNotPreviouslyRptInd0false
IRS990EZ/BooksInCareOfDetail/PersonNm0Sherry Dorris
IRS990EZ/BooksInCareOfDetail/PhoneNum08059857273
IRS990EZ/BooksInCareOfDetail/USAddress/AddressLine1Txt02596 Cabin Cove
IRS990EZ/BooksInCareOfDetail/USAddress/CityNm0Port Hueneme
IRS990EZ/BooksInCareOfDetail/USAddress/StateAbbreviationCd0CA
IRS990EZ/BooksInCareOfDetail/USAddress/ZIPCd093041
IRS990EZ/CashSavingsAndInvestmentsGrp/BOYAmt039054
IRS990EZ/CashSavingsAndInvestmentsGrp/EOYAmt067209
IRS990EZ/ChgMadeToOrgnzngDocNotRptInd0false
IRS990EZ/ContributionsGiftsGrantsEtcAmt0159776
IRS990EZ/CostOfGoodsSoldAmt00
IRS990EZ/CostOrOtherBasisExpenseSaleAmt00
IRS990EZ/DonorAdvisedFndsInd0false
IRS990EZ/EngagedInExcessBenefitTransInd0false
IRS990EZ/ExcessOrDeficitForYearAmt028155
IRS990EZ/FeesAndOtherPymtToIndCntrctAmt0500
IRS990EZ/FiledScheduleAInd0true
IRS990EZ/ForeignFinancialAccountInd0false
IRS990EZ/ForeignOfficeInd0false
IRS990EZ/Form1120PolFiledInd0false
IRS990EZ/Form990TotalAssetsGrp/BOYAmt039054
IRS990EZ/Form990TotalAssetsGrp/EOYAmt067209
IRS990EZ/FundraisingGrossIncomeAmt00
IRS990EZ/GrossReceiptsAmt0159776
IRS990EZ/InfoInScheduleOPartIInd0X
IRS990EZ/LobbyingActivitiesInd0false
IRS990EZ/MadeLoansToFromOfficersInd0false
IRS990EZ/MethodOfAccountingCashInd0X
IRS990EZ/NetAssetsOrFundBalancesBOYAmt039054
IRS990EZ/NetAssetsOrFundBalancesEOYAmt067209
IRS990EZ/NetAssetsOrFundBalancesGrp/BOYAmt039054
IRS990EZ/NetAssetsOrFundBalancesGrp/EOYAmt067209
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/AverageHrsPerWkDevotedToPosRt00
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/AverageHrsPerWkDevotedToPosRt14.00
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/AverageHrsPerWkDevotedToPosRt24.00
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/AverageHrsPerWkDevotedToPosRt30
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/AverageHrsPerWkDevotedToPosRt46.00
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/AverageHrsPerWkDevotedToPosRt510.00
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/AverageHrsPerWkDevotedToPosRt64.00
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/AverageHrsPerWkDevotedToPosRt74.00
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/AverageHrsPerWkDevotedToPosRt80
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/AverageHrsPerWkDevotedToPosRt94.00
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/AverageHrsPerWkDevotedToPosRt104.00
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/CompensationAmt00
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/CompensationAmt18670
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/CompensationAmt20
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/CompensationAmt30
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/CompensationAmt40
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/CompensationAmt57173
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/CompensationAmt60
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/CompensationAmt70
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/CompensationAmt80
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/CompensationAmt95960
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/CompensationAmt100
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/PersonNm0RACHEL AMECHE
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/PersonNm1CYNTHIA HARTLEY
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/PersonNm2LINDSAY TALLY
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/PersonNm3KAITLYN ODEA
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/PersonNm4SANDY HEDRICK
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/PersonNm5ALECIA SMITH
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/PersonNm6FRANK DeMARTINO
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/PersonNm7SABRINA KENNEDY
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/PersonNm8VINCE KINSCH
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/PersonNm9DEBRA BARRINGER
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/PersonNm10SHERRY DORRIS
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/TitleTxt0Vice President
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/TitleTxt1Executive Dir.
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/TitleTxt2Director
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/TitleTxt3Director
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/TitleTxt4Director
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/TitleTxt5Director
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/TitleTxt6Director
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/TitleTxt7Secretary
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/TitleTxt8President
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/TitleTxt9Director
IRS990EZ/OfficerDirectorTrusteeEmplGrp/TitleTxt10Treasurer
IRS990EZ/OperateHospitalInd0false
IRS990EZ/Organization501c3Ind0X
IRS990EZ/OrganizationDissolvedEtcInd0false
IRS990EZ/OrganizationHadUBIInd0false
IRS990EZ/OtherExpensesTotalAmt0109056
IRS990EZ/PartVIHghstPdCntrctProfSrvcTxt0NONE
IRS990EZ/PartVIOfCompOfHghstPdEmplTxt0NONE
IRS990EZ/PoliticalCampaignActyInd0false
IRS990EZ/PrimaryExemptPurposeTxt0The mission of the Ventura Audubon Society is to promote at the local level, by education and action, the protection and restoration of bird populations and wildlife habitat for the benefit of humanity and the earth's biodiversity.
IRS990EZ/PrintingPublicationsPostageAmt0262
IRS990EZ/ProgramSrvcAccomplishmentGrp/DescriptionProgramSrvcAccomTxt0Education
IRS990EZ/ProgramSrvcAccomplishmentGrp/DescriptionProgramSrvcAccomTxt1Shorebird Recovery Program
IRS990EZ/ProgramSrvcAccomplishmentGrp/DescriptionProgramSrvcAccomTxt2NFWF
IRS990EZ/ProgramSrvcAccomplishmentGrp/GrantsAndAllocationsAmt056070
IRS990EZ/ProgramSrvcAccomplishmentGrp/GrantsAndAllocationsAmt143700
IRS990EZ/ProgramSrvcAccomplishmentGrp/ProgramServiceExpensesAmt03413
IRS990EZ/ProgramSrvcAccomplishmentGrp/ProgramServiceExpensesAmt174993
IRS990EZ/ProgramSrvcAccomplishmentGrp/ProgramServiceExpensesAmt243700
IRS990EZ/ProhibitedTaxShelterTransInd0false
IRS990EZ/RelatedOrganizationCtrlEntInd0false
IRS990EZ/SalariesOtherCompEmplBnftAmt021803
IRS990EZ/SchoolOperatingInd0false
IRS990EZ/SpecialEventsDirectExpensesAmt00
IRS990EZ/SubjectToProxyTaxInd0false
IRS990EZ/TanningServicesProvidedInd0false
IRS990EZ/TaxImposedOnOrganizationMgrAmt00
IRS990EZ/TaxImposedUnderIRC4911Amt00
IRS990EZ/TaxImposedUnderIRC4912Amt00
IRS990EZ/TaxImposedUnderIRC4955Amt00
IRS990EZ/TaxReimbursedByOrganizationAmt00
IRS990EZ/TotalExpensesAmt0131621
IRS990EZ/TotalProgramServiceExpensesAmt0122106
IRS990EZ/TotalRevenueAmt0159776
IRS990EZ/TransactionWithControlEntInd0false
IRS990EZ/TrnsfrExmptNonChrtblRltdOrgInd0false
IRS990EZ/TypeOfOrganizationCorpInd0X
IRS990EZ/WebsiteAddressTxt0www.venturaaudubon.org
IRS990ScheduleA/GiftsGrantsContriRcvd170Grp/CurrentTaxYearAmt0159776
IRS990ScheduleA/GiftsGrantsContriRcvd170Grp/CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt0156302
IRS990ScheduleA/GiftsGrantsContriRcvd170Grp/CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt0107658
IRS990ScheduleA/GiftsGrantsContriRcvd170Grp/CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt040778
IRS990ScheduleA/GiftsGrantsContriRcvd170Grp/CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt051779
IRS990ScheduleA/GiftsGrantsContriRcvd170Grp/TotalAmt0516293
IRS990ScheduleA/GovtFurnSrvcFcltsVl170Grp/TotalAmt00
IRS990ScheduleA/GrossInvestmentIncome170Grp/TotalAmt00
IRS990ScheduleA/OtherIncome170Grp/TotalAmt00
IRS990ScheduleA/PublicOrganization170Ind0X
IRS990ScheduleA/PublicSupportCY170Pct01.00000
IRS990ScheduleA/PublicSupportPY170Pct01.00000
IRS990ScheduleA/PublicSupportTotal170Amt0516293
IRS990ScheduleA/SubstantialContributorsTotAmt00
IRS990ScheduleA/TaxRevLeviedOrgnztnlBnft170Grp/TotalAmt00
IRS990ScheduleA/ThirtyThrPctSuprtTestsCY170Ind0X
IRS990ScheduleA/TotalCalendarYear170Grp/CurrentTaxYearAmt0159776
IRS990ScheduleA/TotalCalendarYear170Grp/CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt0156302
IRS990ScheduleA/TotalCalendarYear170Grp/CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt0107658
IRS990ScheduleA/TotalCalendarYear170Grp/CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt040778
IRS990ScheduleA/TotalCalendarYear170Grp/CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt051779
IRS990ScheduleA/TotalCalendarYear170Grp/TotalAmt0516293
IRS990ScheduleA/TotalSupportAmt0516293
IRS990ScheduleA/UnrelatedBusinessNetIncm170Grp/TotalAmt00
IRS990ScheduleB/ContributorInformationGrp/ContributorBusinessName/BusinessNameLine10RESTRICTED
IRS990ScheduleB/ContributorInformationGrp/ContributorNum0RESTRICTED
IRS990ScheduleB/ContributorInformationGrp/ContributorUSAddress/AddressLine10RESTRICTED
IRS990ScheduleB/ContributorInformationGrp/ContributorUSAddress/AddressLine20RESTRICTED
IRS990ScheduleB/ContributorInformationGrp/ContributorUSAddress/City0RESTRICTED
IRS990ScheduleB/ContributorInformationGrp/ContributorUSAddress/State0RESTRICTED
IRS990ScheduleB/ContributorInformationGrp/ContributorUSAddress/ZIPCode0RESTRICTED
IRS990ScheduleB/ContributorInformationGrp/TotalContributionsAmt0RESTRICTED
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/ExplanationTxt0Advertising and Promotion $71
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/ExplanationTxt1Office Expenses $520
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/ExplanationTxt2Information Technology $1132
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/ExplanationTxt3Insurance $2500
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/ExplanationTxt4PROGRAM EXPENSES $100303
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/ExplanationTxt5SOFTWARE $1825
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/ExplanationTxt6BIRDATHON $1232
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/ExplanationTxt7STORAGE $684
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/ExplanationTxt8SPECIAL PROJECTS $440
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/ExplanationTxt9BANK FEES $264
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/ExplanationTxt10Taxes $75
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/ExplanationTxt11FEES $10
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/FormAndLineReferenceDesc0Other Expenses.1001
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/FormAndLineReferenceDesc1Other Expenses.1002
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/FormAndLineReferenceDesc2Other Expenses.1003
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/FormAndLineReferenceDesc3Other Expenses.1012
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/FormAndLineReferenceDesc4Other Expenses.1
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/FormAndLineReferenceDesc5Other Expenses.2
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/FormAndLineReferenceDesc6Other Expenses.3
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/FormAndLineReferenceDesc7Other Expenses.4
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/FormAndLineReferenceDesc8Other Expenses.5
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/FormAndLineReferenceDesc9Other Expenses.6
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/FormAndLineReferenceDesc10Other Expenses.8
IRS990ScheduleO/SupplementalInformationDetail/FormAndLineReferenceDesc11Other Expenses.9
ReturnHeader/AdditionalFilerInformation/TrustedCustomerGrp/AuthenticationAssuranceLevelCd0AAL1
ReturnHeader/AdditionalFilerInformation/TrustedCustomerGrp/FederatedAssuranceLevelCd0FAL1
ReturnHeader/AdditionalFilerInformation/TrustedCustomerGrp/IdentityAssuranceLevelCd0IAL1
ReturnHeader/AdditionalFilerInformation/TrustedCustomerGrp/TrustedCustomerCd02
ReturnHeader/BuildTS02023-04-26 12:10:37Z
ReturnHeader/BusinessOfficerGrp/DiscussWithPaidPreparerInd0true
ReturnHeader/BusinessOfficerGrp/PersonNm0VINCE KINSCH
ReturnHeader/BusinessOfficerGrp/PersonTitleTxt0President
ReturnHeader/BusinessOfficerGrp/SignatureDt02023-11-07
ReturnHeader/Filer/BusinessName/BusinessNameLine1Txt0VENTURA AUDUBON SOCIETY
ReturnHeader/Filer/BusinessNameControlTxt0VENT
ReturnHeader/Filer/EIN0953538623
ReturnHeader/Filer/PhoneNum08056284044
ReturnHeader/Filer/USAddress/AddressLine1Txt0PO BOX 24198
ReturnHeader/Filer/USAddress/CityNm0VENTURA
ReturnHeader/Filer/USAddress/StateAbbreviationCd0CA
ReturnHeader/Filer/USAddress/ZIPCd093002
ReturnHeader/IRSResponsiblePrtyInfoCurrInd0true
ReturnHeader/PreparerFirmGrp/PreparerFirmName/BusinessNameLine1Txt0HAYMAN CONSULTING
ReturnHeader/PreparerFirmGrp/PreparerUSAddress/AddressLine1Txt04616 TEMPLETON ST
ReturnHeader/PreparerFirmGrp/PreparerUSAddress/CityNm0VENTURA
ReturnHeader/PreparerFirmGrp/PreparerUSAddress/StateAbbreviationCd0CA
ReturnHeader/PreparerFirmGrp/PreparerUSAddress/ZIPCd093003
ReturnHeader/PreparerPersonGrp/PhoneNum08054077599
ReturnHeader/PreparerPersonGrp/PreparerPersonNm0Mark Hayman
ReturnHeader/PreparerPersonGrp/SelfEmployedInd0X
ReturnHeader/ReturnTs02023-11-07T21:57:37-08:00
ReturnHeader/ReturnTypeCd0990EZ
ReturnHeader/SigningOfficerGrp/PersonFullName/PersonFirstNm0VINCE
ReturnHeader/SigningOfficerGrp/PersonFullName/PersonLastNm0KINSCH
ReturnHeader/TaxPeriodBeginDt02022-07-01
ReturnHeader/TaxPeriodEndDt02023-06-30
ReturnHeader/TaxYr02022

Document Assets

No mirrored PDF or thumbnail assets are attached yet.