Civic Intelligence

Baldwin-Edwards Charitable Foundation

EIN 20-2545678 • Aspen, CO

205 South Galena StreetAspen, CO 81611
Siviq Scores

Precomputed percentiles relative to similar nonprofits. These scores are descriptive rather than judgmental.

Liabilities / Assets

63rd percentile

0.00x

Tied with the lowest-debt nonprofits in its peer group.

<$500k nonprofits • Source year 2016

Liabilities / Revenue

Score unavailable

No value available

Liabilities-to-revenue requires both liabilities and revenue on the latest valid filing.

Source year 2016

Net Margin

Score unavailable

No value available

Net margin requires both revenue and expenses on the latest valid filing.

Source year 2016

Top Officer Pay

81st percentile

$0

Higher top officer pay than 81% of similar nonprofits.

<$500k nonprofits • Source year 2016

Asset Growth

13th percentile

-93%

Faster asset growth than 13% of similar nonprofits.

<$500k nonprofits • Annualized from 2015 to 2016

Revenue Growth

4th percentile

-100%

Faster revenue growth than 4% of similar nonprofits.

<$500k nonprofits • Annualized from 2015 to 2016

Balance Sheet
Liabilities / Assets63rd percentile

Assets

Down

$879

Down $11,405 (-93%) from 2015

Liabilities

Flat

$0

Flat from 2015

Net Assets

Down

$879

Down $11,405 (-93%) from 2015

Operations
Liabilities / RevenueScore unavailableNet MarginScore unavailable

Revenue

Down

$0

Down $14 (-100%) from 2015

Expenses

Up

$11,405

Up $3,872 (+51%) from 2015

Net Income

Down

-$11,405

Down $3,886 (-52%) from 2015

Trend Graphs

Balance Sheet Trend

Asset Growth13th percentile

Grouped bars show assets, liabilities, and net assets across loaded filings.

$400K$300K$200K$100K$0Assets 2010: $311,502Liabilities 2010: $285,342Net Assets 2010: $26,1602010Assets 2011: $280,117Liabilities 2011: $260,206Net Assets 2011: $19,9112011Assets 2012: $207,212Liabilities 2012: $180,306Net Assets 2012: $26,9062012Assets 2013: $134,693Liabilities 2013: $113,706Net Assets 2013: $20,9872013Assets 2014: $63,647Liabilities 2014: $56,156Net Assets 2014: $7,4912014Assets 2015: $12,284Liabilities 2015: $0Net Assets 2015: $12,2842015Assets 2016: $879Liabilities 2016: $0Net Assets 2016: $8792016

Highlighted filing

2016

Assets$879
Liabilities$0
Net Assets$879
Open 2016 Filing

Operations Trend

Revenue Growth4th percentile

Revenue, expenses, and net income by year, with the latest filing highlighted.

$100K$50K$0-$50K-$100KExpenses 2010: $78,6252010Expenses 2011: $21,9972011Expenses 2012: $72,9292012Revenue 2013: $258Expenses 2013: $69,378Net Income 2013: -$69,1202013Revenue 2014: $304Expenses 2014: $58,895Net Income 2014: -$58,5912014Revenue 2015: $14Expenses 2015: $7,533Net Income 2015: -$7,5192015Revenue 2016: $0Expenses 2016: $11,405Net Income 2016: -$11,4052016

Highlighted filing

2016

Revenue$0
Expenses$11,405
Net Income-$11,405
Open 2016 Filing

Filings

Most recent year

2016 • Form 990PFXML pending. An XML filing is linked for this year, but detailed extraction is still pending.

Open filing
Assets
$879
Liabilities
$0
Net assets
$879
Revenue
$0
Expenses
$11,405
Net income
-$11,405
Balance SheetOperations
YearAssetsLiabilitiesNet AssetsRevenueExpensesNet Income
2016XML pending. An XML filing is linked for this year, but detailed extraction is still pending.$0.01$0.00$0.01$0.00$0.11$0.11
2015Detailed filing. Detailed filing data is available for this year.$0.12$0.00$0.12$0.00$0.08$0.08
2014Detailed filing. Detailed filing data is available for this year.$0.64$0.56$0.07$0.00$0.59$0.59
2013Detailed filing. Detailed filing data is available for this year.$1.35$1.14$0.21$0.00$0.69$0.69
2012Detailed filing. Detailed filing data is available for this year.$2.07$1.80$0.27$0.73
2011Detailed filing. Detailed filing data is available for this year.$2.80$2.60$0.20$0.22
2010Detailed filing. Detailed filing data is available for this year.$3.12$2.85$0.26$0.79
Latest Detailed Filing

The latest 2016 filing currently has linked XML that has not been fully parsed yet. Showing the latest detailed filing from 2015 below.

Jump To
Filing Snapshot
Filing Period
Jan 1, 2015 to Dec 31, 2015
Signed
Mar 8, 2016
Return Version
2015v2.0
Compensation and Service Providers
Top Officer Pay81st percentile

Employees

NameTitleFull / Part TimeBaseOtherTotal
RICHARD W L EDWARDSChairman-$0--
Grants and Assistance

Foundation Grants and Related Investments

TypeRecipientPurposeStatusLocationAmount
Paid GrantASPEN ART MUSEUMNEW MUSEUMYESASPEN, CO, US$6,156
Filing and Contact Details

Filer

Filer Name
Baldwin-edwards Charitable Foundation
EIN
20-2545678
Phone
9709201800
Address
205 SOUTH GALENA STREET, ASPEN, CO 81611

Signing Officer

Name
Richard W L Edwards
Title
Chairman
Signed
2016-03-08
Discuss with paid preparer
Yes

Preparer

Firm
Goldberg and Goldberg Pc
Address
2520 S Grand Ave Suite 114, Glenwood Springs, CO 81601-4196
Preparer
Janet Goldberg
Phone
9709459811
Raw XML Appendix180 raw XML fields

This appendix keeps the raw XML leaves available for debugging and edge-case review. The human report above is the primary experience.

Path#Value
AccountingFeesSchedule/AccountingFeesDetail/AdjustedNetIncomeAmt00
AccountingFeesSchedule/AccountingFeesDetail/Amt01365
AccountingFeesSchedule/AccountingFeesDetail/DisbursementsCharitablePrpsAmt00
AccountingFeesSchedule/AccountingFeesDetail/NetInvestmentIncomeAmt00
IRS990PF/AnalysisIncomeProducingActyGrp/IntOnSavAndTempCashInvstGrp/UnrelatedBusinessTaxblIncmAmt014
IRS990PF/AnalysisIncomeProducingActyGrp/SubtotalsIncmProducingActyGrp/UnrelatedBusinessTaxblIncmAmt014
IRS990PF/AnalysisIncomeProducingActyGrp/TotalIncomeProducingActyAmt014
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/AccountingFeesRevAndExpnssAmt01365
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/AdjustedNetIncomeAmt014
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/ContriPaidDsbrsChrtblAmt06156
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/ContriPaidRevAndExpnssAmt06156
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/ExcessRevenueOverExpensesAmt0-7519
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/InterestOnSavingsAdjNetIncmAmt014
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/InterestOnSavNetInvstIncmAmt014
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/InterestOnSavRevAndExpnssAmt014
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/NetInvestmentIncomeAmt014
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/OtherExpensesRevAndExpnssAmt012
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/ScheduleBNotRequiredInd0X
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/TotalAdjNetIncmAmt014
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/TotalExpensesDsbrsChrtblAmt06156
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/TotalExpensesNetInvstIncmAmt00
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/TotalExpensesRevAndExpnssAmt07533
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/TotalNetInvstIncmAmt014
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/TotalRevAndExpnssAmt014
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/TotOprExpensesDsbrsChrtblAmt00
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/TotOprExpensesNetInvstIncmAmt00
IRS990PF/AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses/TotOprExpensesRevAndExpnssAmt01377
IRS990PF/ChgInNetAssetsFundBalancesGrp/ExcessRevenueOverExpensesAmt0-7519
IRS990PF/ChgInNetAssetsFundBalancesGrp/OtherIncreasesAmt012312
IRS990PF/ChgInNetAssetsFundBalancesGrp/SubtotalAmt012284
IRS990PF/ChgInNetAssetsFundBalancesGrp/TotNetAstOrFundBalancesBOYAmt07491
IRS990PF/ChgInNetAssetsFundBalancesGrp/TotNetAstOrFundBalancesEOYAmt012284
IRS990PF/DistributableAmountGrp/DistributableAsAdjustedAmt00
IRS990PF/ExciseTaxBasedOnInvstIncmGrp/InvestmentIncomeExciseTaxAmt00
IRS990PF/FMVAssetsEOYAmt00
IRS990PF/Form990PFBalanceSheetsGrp/OrganizationFollowsSFAS117Ind0X
IRS990PF/Form990PFBalanceSheetsGrp/OtherLiabilitiesBOYAmt056156
IRS990PF/Form990PFBalanceSheetsGrp/SavAndTempCashInvstBOYAmt063647
IRS990PF/Form990PFBalanceSheetsGrp/SavAndTempCashInvstEOYAmt012284
IRS990PF/Form990PFBalanceSheetsGrp/TotalAssetsBOYAmt063647
IRS990PF/Form990PFBalanceSheetsGrp/TotalAssetsEOYAmt012284
IRS990PF/Form990PFBalanceSheetsGrp/TotalAssetsEOYFMVAmt00
IRS990PF/Form990PFBalanceSheetsGrp/TotalLiabilitiesBOYAmt056156
IRS990PF/Form990PFBalanceSheetsGrp/TotalLiabilitiesEOYAmt00
IRS990PF/Form990PFBalanceSheetsGrp/TotalLiabilitiesNetAstBOYAmt063647
IRS990PF/Form990PFBalanceSheetsGrp/TotalLiabilitiesNetAstEOYAmt012284
IRS990PF/Form990PFBalanceSheetsGrp/TotNetAstOrFundBalancesBOYAmt07491
IRS990PF/Form990PFBalanceSheetsGrp/TotNetAstOrFundBalancesEOYAmt012284
IRS990PF/Form990PFBalanceSheetsGrp/UnrestrictedBOYAmt07491
IRS990PF/Form990PFBalanceSheetsGrp/UnrestrictedEOYAmt012284
IRS990PF/MethodOfAccountingAccrualInd0X
IRS990PF/MinimumInvestmentReturnGrp/AdjustedTotalFMVOfUnusedAstAmt00
IRS990PF/MinimumInvestmentReturnGrp/AverageMonthlyCashBalancesAmt00
IRS990PF/MinimumInvestmentReturnGrp/AverageMonthlyFMVOfSecAmt00
IRS990PF/MinimumInvestmentReturnGrp/CashDeemedCharitableAmt00
IRS990PF/MinimumInvestmentReturnGrp/FMVAllOtherNoncharitableAstAmt00
IRS990PF/MinimumInvestmentReturnGrp/MinimumInvestmentReturnAmt00
IRS990PF/MinimumInvestmentReturnGrp/NetVlNoncharitableAssetsAmt00
IRS990PF/MinimumInvestmentReturnGrp/ReductionClaimedAmt00
IRS990PF/MinimumInvestmentReturnGrp/TotalFMVOfUnusedAssetsAmt00
IRS990PF/OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplInfoGrp/CompOfHghstPdCntrctOrNONETxt0NONE
IRS990PF/OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplInfoGrp/CompOfHghstPdEmplOrNONETxt0NONE
IRS990PF/OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplInfoGrp/OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplGrp/AverageHrsPerWkDevotedToPosRt02.00
IRS990PF/OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplInfoGrp/OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplGrp/CompensationAmt00
IRS990PF/OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplInfoGrp/OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplGrp/PersonNm0RICHARD W L EDWARDS
IRS990PF/OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplInfoGrp/OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplGrp/TitleTxt0Chairman
IRS990PF/OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplInfoGrp/OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplGrp/USAddress/AddressLine1Txt0205 S GALENA STREET
IRS990PF/OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplInfoGrp/OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplGrp/USAddress/CityNm0ASPEN
IRS990PF/OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplInfoGrp/OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplGrp/USAddress/StateAbbreviationCd0CO
IRS990PF/OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplInfoGrp/OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplGrp/USAddress/ZIPCd081611
IRS990PF/Organization501c3ExemptPFInd0X
IRS990PF/QualifyingDistriPartXIIGrp/AdjustedQualifyingDistriAmt06156
IRS990PF/QualifyingDistriPartXIIGrp/ExpensesAndContributionsAmt06156
IRS990PF/QualifyingDistriPartXIIGrp/QualifyingDistributionsAmt06156
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/ActsFailToQlfyAsExceptionsInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/BrrwOrLendDisqualifiedPrsnInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/BusinessHoldingsInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/ExcessBusinessHoldingsInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/FurnGoodsDisqualifiedPrsnInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/GrantsToIndividualsInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/GrantsToOrganizationsInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/InfluenceElectionInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/InfluenceLegislationInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/JeopardyInvestmentsInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/MaintainedExpenditureRspnsInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/NoncharitablePurposeInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/PayCompDisqualifiedPrsnInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/PaymentToGovernmentOfficialInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/PayPremiumsPrsnlBnftCntrctInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/ProceedsOrNetIncomeInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/ProhibitedTaxShelterTransInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/RcvFndsToPayPrsnlBnftCntrctInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/SaleOrExchDisqualifiedPrsnInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/TransactionsFailToQlfyAsExcInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/TransferAstDisqualifiedPrsnInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/UncorrectedPriorActsInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/UncorrectedPYJeopardyInvstInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/UndistributedIncomePYInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp/UndistrIncmSect4942a2NotAppInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/ActivitiesNotPreviouslyRptInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/AtLeast5000InAssetsInd0true
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/ChangesToArticlesOrBylawsInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/ComplyWithPublicInspRqrInd0true
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/DonorAdvisedFundInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/ForeignAccountsQuestionInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/Form1120POLFiledInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/Form990PFFiledWithAttyGenInd0true
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/Form990TFiledInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/LegislativePoliticalActyInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/LocationOfBooksUSAddress/AddressLine1Txt02520 S GRAND AVE STE 114
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/LocationOfBooksUSAddress/CityNm0GLENWOOD SPRINGS
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/LocationOfBooksUSAddress/StateAbbreviationCd0CO
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/LocationOfBooksUSAddress/ZIPCd081601
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/MoreThan100SpentInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/NewSubstantialContributorsInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/OrganizationDissolvedEtcInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/OwnControlledEntityInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/PersonsWithBooksName/BusinessNameLine1Txt0JANET GOLDBERG
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/PhoneNum09709459811
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/PrivateOperatingFoundationInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/Section508eRqrSatisfiedInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/UnrelatedBusIncmOverLimitInd0false
IRS990PF/StatementsRegardingActyGrp/WebsiteAddressTxt0N/A
IRS990PF/SupplementaryInformationGrp/GrantOrContributionPdDurYrGrp/Amt06156
IRS990PF/SupplementaryInformationGrp/GrantOrContributionPdDurYrGrp/GrantOrContributionPurposeTxt0NEW MUSEUM
IRS990PF/SupplementaryInformationGrp/GrantOrContributionPdDurYrGrp/RecipientBusinessName/BusinessNameLine1Txt0ASPEN ART MUSEUM
IRS990PF/SupplementaryInformationGrp/GrantOrContributionPdDurYrGrp/RecipientFoundationStatusTxt0YES
IRS990PF/SupplementaryInformationGrp/GrantOrContributionPdDurYrGrp/RecipientRelationshipTxt0N/A
IRS990PF/SupplementaryInformationGrp/GrantOrContributionPdDurYrGrp/RecipientUSAddress/AddressLine1Txt0590 N MILL ST
IRS990PF/SupplementaryInformationGrp/GrantOrContributionPdDurYrGrp/RecipientUSAddress/CityNm0ASPEN
IRS990PF/SupplementaryInformationGrp/GrantOrContributionPdDurYrGrp/RecipientUSAddress/StateAbbreviationCd0CO
IRS990PF/SupplementaryInformationGrp/GrantOrContributionPdDurYrGrp/RecipientUSAddress/ZIPCd081611
IRS990PF/SupplementaryInformationGrp/OnlyContriToPreselectedInd0X
IRS990PF/SupplementaryInformationGrp/TotalGrantOrContriPdDurYrAmt06156
IRS990PF/TrnsfrTransRlnNonchrtblEOGrp/LoansOrLoanGuaranteesInd0false
IRS990PF/TrnsfrTransRlnNonchrtblEOGrp/PerformanceOfServicesEtcInd0false
IRS990PF/TrnsfrTransRlnNonchrtblEOGrp/PurchaseOfAssetsNonchrtblEOInd0false
IRS990PF/TrnsfrTransRlnNonchrtblEOGrp/ReimbursementArrangementsInd0false
IRS990PF/TrnsfrTransRlnNonchrtblEOGrp/RelationshipsNonchrtblEOInd0false
IRS990PF/TrnsfrTransRlnNonchrtblEOGrp/RentalOfFacilitiesOthAssetsInd0false
IRS990PF/TrnsfrTransRlnNonchrtblEOGrp/SalesOrExchangesOfAssetsInd0false
IRS990PF/TrnsfrTransRlnNonchrtblEOGrp/SharingOfFacilitiesEtcInd0false
IRS990PF/TrnsfrTransRlnNonchrtblEOGrp/TrnsfrOfCashToNonchrtblEOInd0false
IRS990PF/TrnsfrTransRlnNonchrtblEOGrp/TrnsfrOtherAssetNonchrtblEOInd0false
IRS990PF/UndistributedIncomeGrp/CorpusDistri170b1EOr4942g3Amt06156
IRS990PF/UndistributedIncomeGrp/DistributableAsAdjustedAmt00
IRS990PF/UndistributedIncomeGrp/QualifyingDistributionsAmt06156
IRS990PF/UndistributedIncomeGrp/RemainingDistriFromCorpusAmt06156
IRS990PF/UndistributedIncomeGrp/TotalCorpusAmt06156
IRS990PF/UndistributedIncomeGrp/TreatedAsDistriFromCorpusAmt00
IRS990PF/UndistributedIncomeGrp/UndistributedIncomeCYAmt00
OtherExpensesSchedule/OtherExpensesScheduleGrp/Desc0BANK CHARGES
OtherExpensesSchedule/OtherExpensesScheduleGrp/Desc1TAXES
OtherExpensesSchedule/OtherExpensesScheduleGrp/RevenueAndExpensesPerBooksAmt06
OtherExpensesSchedule/OtherExpensesScheduleGrp/RevenueAndExpensesPerBooksAmt16
ReturnHeader/BuildTS02016-09-27 15:27:22Z
ReturnHeader/BusinessOfficerGrp/DiscussWithPaidPreparerInd0true
ReturnHeader/BusinessOfficerGrp/PersonNm0RICHARD W L EDWARDS
ReturnHeader/BusinessOfficerGrp/PersonTitleTxt0Chairman
ReturnHeader/BusinessOfficerGrp/SignatureDt02016-03-08
ReturnHeader/Filer/BusinessName/BusinessNameLine1Txt0BALDWIN-EDWARDS CHARITABLE FOUNDATION
ReturnHeader/Filer/BusinessNameControlTxt0BALD
ReturnHeader/Filer/EIN0202545678
ReturnHeader/Filer/PhoneNum09709201800
ReturnHeader/Filer/USAddress/AddressLine1Txt0205 SOUTH GALENA STREET
ReturnHeader/Filer/USAddress/CityNm0ASPEN
ReturnHeader/Filer/USAddress/StateAbbreviationCd0CO
ReturnHeader/Filer/USAddress/ZIPCd081611
ReturnHeader/PreparerFirmGrp/PreparerFirmName/BusinessNameLine1Txt0GOLDBERG AND GOLDBERG PC
ReturnHeader/PreparerFirmGrp/PreparerUSAddress/AddressLine1Txt02520 S Grand Ave Suite 114
ReturnHeader/PreparerFirmGrp/PreparerUSAddress/CityNm0Glenwood Springs
ReturnHeader/PreparerFirmGrp/PreparerUSAddress/StateAbbreviationCd0CO
ReturnHeader/PreparerFirmGrp/PreparerUSAddress/ZIPCd0816014196
ReturnHeader/PreparerPersonGrp/PhoneNum09709459811
ReturnHeader/PreparerPersonGrp/PreparerPersonNm0JANET GOLDBERG
ReturnHeader/ReturnTs02016-03-08T13:42:28-08:00
ReturnHeader/ReturnTypeCd0990PF
ReturnHeader/TaxPeriodBeginDt02015-01-01
ReturnHeader/TaxPeriodEndDt02015-12-31
ReturnHeader/TaxYr02015

Document Assets

No mirrored PDF or thumbnail assets are attached yet.